13 Comments

Great reporting. Thank you.

Expand full comment

Great article. Balanced, reasoned and researched, unlike some of the ludicrous Kremlin fan-boy comments below.

Expand full comment

Anyone who still (5 months later) thinks the distraction event around Kiev was a military defeat for Russia is probably not worth reading.

You could have saved me a lot of time by starting with that.

2014 made it very very clear that Russia was being targeted by Nato actively. Russia is not one of a coalition like Nato or the old Warsaw Pakt. It is a single nation facing all of Nato. It also is greatly appreciated by those it protects - Abkhazia, S Ossetia, and especially by all native Syrians where it has been fighting Nato backed terrorists for 7 years while US steals Syrian oil revenue..

Spending 4.1% of GDP only on Defence when the US (backed solidly by Nato and with no natural enemies) spends 3.5% is remarkably LOW.

That it gets in many areas a superior product to the US is a testament to Russia's resolve and technical achievements.

Russia has Khinzal's, US does not.

Expand full comment

==="...It is a single nation facing all of Nato..."===

What propaganda crap have you been reading? What is one nation? Where do you live? They laughed pretty hard. ))))

Expand full comment

Thank you for your comment!

There are some people you can't help... Maybe Putin is alone because he pushes away other countries! XD

I don't know why pro-Putin fans have such a victim complex...

Expand full comment

And there are the really ideological, but there are few of them, mostly zazombified, they have never seen or understood what real freedom is. They have been brainwashed by Pioneer, Komsomol, Communism since school...

Вот комментарий одной учительницы:

"Анастасия Карлаш

Практически то же самое я объяснила сыну в первом классе, и объясняю теперь своим ученикам. Что мою работу оплатило государство из карманов ваших родителей. Вот именно эту тему ровно один раз. Пропустили урок - значит, спустили деньги ваших родителей в унитаз. И что нет никакого бесплатного образования, медицины и подобной бесплатной туфты. Забудьте. И я за бесплатно второй раз тему жевать вам не буду 🤷‍♀.

Пока не вобьёшь это в голову с детства большинству - так и будут расти поколения халявщиков и терпил. Собственно, все и растут, наследие советского «бесплатного» 🤦‍♀."

https://sun9-47.userapi.com/impg/rRLLN2VMYlyfRyHiGdRZMPzolaE8ld9B-wgp_g/rMIUmGp6Khc.jpg?size=536x248&quality=95&sign=25889c1509bc72544ffa9f345af2187a&type=album

Expand full comment

My wife, 22 years ago, when she saw Putin on TV, said: "That's it, the collapse of Russia." She just looked at the man and gave out this phrase, she saw him for the first time and knew nothing about him. Regarding our discussion, see these publications:

https://chispa1707.livejournal.com/3771920.html

https://chispa1707.livejournal.com/3772891.html

Сhispa1707 is a literate person. ) By the way, at the beginning of SVO, he published a study, with maps, explanations, why this is all being done. But then he got scared and deleted it. )

Expand full comment

I agree, as even Pope Francis has talked about NATO "barking" at Russia. https://socraticgadfly.blogspot.com/2022/05/kissinger-calls-for-negotiated-peace-on.html That still doesn't mean Putin didn't screw the pooch on launching this actual war, or in the preparations for it. As for the attempt to seize Kiev/Kyiv and its failure? Nice PR try, but no good.

Expand full comment

Coming from a nazi slogan that is a bit rich - the one thing your guys are not doing right now is coping at all. Throwing untrained troops at merciless fire poor sods.

Your duty if you think anything of Ukraine is to push hard for a withdrawal at any cost and an end to the deaths of (mostly now) innocent Ukrainian troops.

Expand full comment

Bit rich coming from a Nazi.

I thought Nazi slogans would be your thing.

Expand full comment

This article suggests that Russian military spending is something other countries should fear, then pulls the carpet from under its own feet by pointing out how badly Russian forces have performed in the invasion of Ukraine and how much of that military spending has been siphoned off via corrupt business people and politicians. It's not clear to me which message we should take away.

Expand full comment

At the same time, Ukraine, starting from the top down with Zelenskyy, is just as corrupt if not more so. https://socraticgadfly.blogspot.com/2022/06/ukraine-week-11-more-truths-come-out-on.html

Expand full comment